31 Mart 2008 Pazartesi

Cityshape: communicating and evaluating community design

UD 514 5th week Submission

Murat Cevikayak

152002001

To help counteract the view that community design decisions are merely expressions of subjective opinion, this paper presents a framework or taxonomy for community planners and designers to use to help citizens understand an evaluate community designs. Utilizing commonly understood words, the taxonomy is grounded in research on basic human needs and on a broad range of concepts from the literature and practice of urban design, urban planning, the building arts, and the visual arts. This article includes an evaluation guide, which provides a coherent, versatile framework for analyzing community design issues. This guide is intended as a diagnostic tool to elicit creative community response and to facilitate more informed discussions.

Although community or urban design plays an essential role in guiding development and enhancing the quality of our built environment, this social art has only recently emerged as a distinct discipline, and definitions of its specific substance, role, and language are still evolving. Opinions differ considerably among both professionals and academics not only about the field's component elements, but also about its relationship to urban planning and the building arts - architecture, landscape architecture, and engineering.

Some assume shortsightedly that community design is nothing more than the arrangement (or rearrangement) of various architectural forms to suit land use regulations. Others focus more insightfully on decoding the interplay among complementary and competing environmental and social forces. Because of involving many different voices speaking in seemingly different languages about complex, dynamic process of community design, Greene presented the taxanomy to resolve the confusion. He describes four basic principles: function, order, identity and appeal.

- Function requires that the design work effectively for the convenience and comfort of all its users

- Order assures that users can become oriented to the environment and understand it.

- Identity denotes a visual image of the environment that reflects special or unique qualities.

- Appeal characterizes a design that gives pleasure to its users over time.

By using these principles Greene describes community design evaluation guide for proposals or site evaluation. Evaluation guide relates the principles, qualities and guidelines of community design to elements of environment. By five point check-off rating system scheme allows the various evaluations to be easily organized and compared.

To sum up, Sherwin Greene makes a transparent, value free taxanomy in terms of understandable by everyone. By describing the evaluation guide, he makes a method of evaluating ideas that often difficult to verbalize. Although he never avoids the parts of subjectivity in this process, he tries to get a general language for citizens and all dicipleners to understand the community design. The process of community design is interdiciplinary and includes citizens because of these seperated parts he gives importance to general communication ehile evaluating the projects to help for easy perception.

5th week Submission

CITYSHAPE – Communicating and Evaluating Community Design

Sherwin Greene

The article presents a framework or taxanomy for community planners and designers to use to help citizens understand and evaluate community dessigns ( author prefers using this term because it conveys a less restrictive sense of geographic scale than the term “urban design”). The taxanomy is more than a theoretical exercise, it is designed as a tool for planning practitioners and their constituencies to apply to design problems in their communities.

For designing a framework for communicating and evaluating community design issues, Grene describes four basic principles: function, order, identity and appeal. These principles, Greene suggests are a synthesis of multiple source and represent attributes that are significant enough to have universal application to all environments. First of all he describes elements of the environment under two groups natural and built as masses, spaces and paths. Then he defines aesthetic requirements according to users needs in terms of physical, psychology and sociology. Because Greene describes community design as a visual experience. While he describing these principles of community design, he also defines taxanomy that defines these principles along with explanatory qualities and guidelines.

• Function is the ability of an environment to satisfy the needs of all its users.
• Order means the clarity of the environment from the users viewpoint
• Identity is the ability of the environment to connote special visual images
• Appeal is the ability of the environment to offer pleasure to its users.

To supply easy perception in terms of citizens he firtly defines community design then communication and at the end evaluation. The community design evaluation guide can be used to evaluate proposals or to make assestments of existing developments. Participants in this assessment can include both professionals and nonprofessionals. Repeated assessments of existing environments, both at night and during the day, can evoke different reactions that are useful starting points for discussion. A five-point rating scale allows for comparisons between participants observations in the assessment process. The five point check off rating system allows the various evaluations to be easily organized and compared. Evaluators first note basic data about project and then record their first imprssions. The next step is to generate a carefully considered rating of the project in terms of each of the four community design principles.

As a conclusion, Greene tries to make a universal language about community design by presenting community design principles. Because complex, dynamic process of community design involves many different voices speaking in seemingly different languages. The taxanomy presented here attempts to resolve the confusion.

Gülnur Vuruskan
152002002

24 Mart 2008 Pazartesi

5th week submission

Onur MENGI
UD 514 Spring’08 IYTE
5th Week Summary Submission

City Shape
Communicating and Evaluating Community Design


This article written by Sherwin Green who is professor of urban planning in the department of urban planning and real estate development, School of Business and Public Management, at The George Washington University, presents a framework or taxonomy for community planners and designers to use to help citizens understand and evaluate community design. It also includes an evaluation guide, which provides a coherent, versatile framework for analyzing community design issues.

In this article, use the term of “communicating” identifies jargon-free and universal language. Skills of designer are always essential. An easily understood terminolgy, however, would encourage public participation in the design process and promote more productive dialogue between designer and designed-for communitiy. Such dialogue could significantly increase the potential for clarifying design issuses and producing good design. Too often professional evaluations of design are nothing more than subjective reactions based on a sophisticated-but poorly articulated-understanding of what works.

Besides “taxonomy” here refers to classification. It is more than a theoretical exercise-a hands-on tool. Also used to structure community design issues or research, to organize concepts and plans, to explain community design and to evaluate existing development s and proposals. This taxonomy can found in approaches of Lynch and Alexander too.

Framework for “evaluation” describes four basic principles of community design;
Function which requires thet the design work effectively for the convenience and comfort of all its users.
Order that assures that users can become oriented to the environment and understand it.
Identity which identifies a visual image of the enviroment that reflects special or unique qualities.
Appeal that characterizes a design that gives pleasure to its users over time.
This process includes taxonomy that defines these, along with explanatory qualities and guidelines and evaluation guide to help participants formulate and structure their responses to places and proposals in terms of the taxonomy.

Evalutioan guide in this article which alike brochure, requires evaluators to decide on the relevance of a wide variety of community design considerations and to organize their responses. The guide consists of 4 step; data, first impression, detailed project evaluation, project relation to context.The five-point check-off rating system allows various evaluations to be easily organized and compared; excellent, good, acceptable, poor and unacceptable.

The ultimate purpose of community design is to improve the function and quality of the built environment. It requires interdisciplinary skills and talents and involves a large clientele. Besides taxonomy attempts to resolve the confusion that is caused by complex and dynamic process of community design involves different voices speaking.

23 Mart 2008 Pazar

Three Theories Of Urban Spatial Design

The research identifies urban design theory with three aproaches which are figure Grand theory, linkage theory and place theory. Eachother is important to understand evolution of modern spaces and the analysis of historic precedents.
Figure-ground theory is based on the connection between voids(figure) and solids (ground). How can we define solids and voids pattern ? And how can we use these relationships in existing pattern? These define structre of the urban space in the city such as major land Marks, open spaces and buildings.
The best example of the figure-ground theory of urban design is Giambattista Nolli’s Map of Rome.İn Nolli, Open space is a positive thing that is more figural than solids. İn spite of the modern concept of space. The open space is characterized like an interier and exterial spaces and with activities.
The term poche is used in figure-groun theory. This term defines walls, colon and other solid of buildings. On the other hand, on exterior, poche is energy the buildings to their neighboring voids.
The figure-ground theory points out that vertical elements on the large ground cause to be vast and horizontal places must be well articulated.
Avlar Aalto of Finland is most important architects about describing achive positive voids. The way is that the structures have more caverage than the surrounding firl and is carved out of mass.
Suzana Torre associates, spatial orientation is defined by the the configuration of urban block that collectively form districts neighborhoods. It is the articulation and differ-entiation of solids and voids that make up the fabric of the city and establish the physical sequences and visual orientation between places.
Figure-ground studies disclosure urban form as six typological patterns solids and voids that are grid, angular, curvilinear, radial cocentric, axial and organic.
Urban solids and voids: Urban solids are defined under three types. First type is public moniments or instiutions which serve as counter pieces in the city fabric. Secand type is predominant field of urban blocks and the last type is formed by directional or edge defining builds that are generally onrepetitive, specialized forms often linear in configuration. Otherwise, urban voids are caracterized by five types such as the entry foyer space or passages, iner block voids, network of streats and squares, public parks and gardens, linear open space system commenly related to major wate features.
The Linkage Theory is based on ‘live’ correctly each parts of city. These lines that invole streats, pedestian roads, linear open space o other, correct buildins to spaces.
This theory regars to organize a system of corrects or a network that establishes a stucture for ordering space.
Compositional form includes individual buildings and typical of Functional planing methots.
Mega form regards connection between individual spaces and includes a frame network in a hierarchical.
Group form results from a incremental accumulation of structures along an armature of communal open space and linkage is naturally and organically evolved.
All three types, Maki emphases linkage as the controlling idea for ordering buildings and spaces in design.
Kenzo Tange, 1960s points out the problem of containing exterior space and designed around circulation patterns.
The Place theory is differ from linkage and figure-ground theory about regarding cultural and human characteristing of physical space. İt is derived from cultrul and regional content. A place only has characteristic of physical but also has sociol. The goal is to achive creating both a place that is well designed physically and a place that has cultrul and historical concepts.
Ian Mcharg brings the term ‘ecological approche’ to design which depends on discovering and working with the qualities of given local.
Kevin Lynch studied on the mental mapping process of individuals in the city and he looked at city in parts in attempt to define a theory of place. He submits three rules for designing city places such as legibility, imageability and structure and identity.
Another approch is that liveable streets projects by Donald Apployard. He points out the physical and social complexities of street and developed an ecology of street life.

17 Mart 2008 Pazartesi

3rd Week Summary Submission_2

Onur MENGI
UD 514 Spring’08 IYTE
3rd Week Summary Submission

Sources of Architectural Form

In this article examine the theories of design within boader context of the history of Western philosophy since theoriests inherited from their culture, attitude and methods. Many theorists worked out variations on five basic idea ranging from the idea that forms are generated within the creative imagination to the idea that they derive from function and climate. These provide the conceptual foundations for most of the historical theories.

“An architectural form is shaped by its intended function”; according to this view, the form of a good building is shaped by the various physical, social, psychological and symbolic functions it it expected to perform. For instance ideal shape of a concert hall should be generated by setting uninterrupted sight lines for every spectator; the shape and location of the entries should be determined by the flow of people to and from their seats; and outside appearence should be shaped by the symbolic role of a concert hall. According to this view, designer must be like a scientist finding some form in a body of pre-existing facts. Besides, if designing building involved nothing more than functions, one would expect no evidence of architect’s personality. Designer in this view avoids, preconceptions, gathering, analysing and synthesizing.

“Architectural form is generated within the creative imagination”; all proponents of this theory agree that inner source is somehow dependent on individual personality of designer and some of designers have a greater gift for employing this source than others. But this theory can not give reasonable explainations for why one hardly find considerable variations in the collected works of society in the same period as well as several generations. While classifying buildings of Renaissance, Gothic or Post-modern show that architects working at the same time tend to use shared ideas, but this theory on its own can not explain how these shared ideas influence individual minds.

“ Architectural form is shaped by the prevailing spirit of the age”; according to this view, no matter how much an individual designer might think he is following personal creative urges, his work will unconsciously respond to the world-view, the source of his design ideas is to be found ‘in the air’ around him. There are several spirits from which a designer must choose, but this freedom of choice contradicts the basic premise of the entire theory.

“Architectural form is determined by the prevailing social and economic conditions”; this theory assets like spirit of age thoery, an architect unconsciously acquire that society’s underlying ideological assumptions. But through centuries it is almost impossible to find one-to-one correlation between socio-economic system and the building form. This theory is insufficent to explain the different form of buildings in the same society.

“Architectural form derives from timeless principles of form that transcend particular designers, cultures and climates”; contrast to other theories above, this suggests that certain universal forms underlie all good architecture, no matter what the particular circumstances of the design problem, designer or culture. While one version of this theory says that ‘there are certain forms like the basilica, the courtyard or the atrium’, another says that ‘this theory looks not to whole forms, but to general principals of form which are more abstract and universal’. But this theory does not explain how they came to be so different given the same starting point. Furthermore how types like skyscrapers or multi storeys first invented. Clearly architects adapt old types for new purposes, but this theory can not explain why.

None of these western theories can not give complete or convincing account of the source of design ideas. Whether consciously or not, many designers today recognize the inadequacies of any single theory, and tend to use two or more. But this juxtaposing does not make a coherent theory. This paradox derives from a conceptual problem built deeply into Western culture’s most fundamental assumptions about the individual and his relationship to the world as the subject-object problem. On the one hand, the individual can be thought of as a physical object in the nature whose actions and behaviour are completely determined, like all other physical objects, but on the other hand individual can just as easily be thought of a s a freely thinking, acting and creative whose actions and behaviour are completely determined by his or her own inner desires free from externalities. From the designer’s personal perspective, one looks like an artist process of inventing new information and giving it to the outside world, while the other looks like a scientific process of taking in existing outside information. Theorists thorughout history have articulated variations on six archetypal interpretations of the individual’s relationship the outside world; theories of creation and theories of knowledge;
Romantism(creation)/Idalism(knowledge); Form is to be find in the inner intuitions of the individual designer. Importance of individual ability.
Positivism(creation)/Empricism(knowledge); Form is merely discovered by designer which is already prefigured by external determinants.
Classicism(creation)/Rationalism(knowledge); Form is to be found outside the mind of designer, as an objective property of the external world. This group is more aware than the other two that necessary balance between mind and world.

16 Mart 2008 Pazar

Sources of Architectural Form

Introduction: The central problem of design theory

Design process is the main question to be studied through time, to answer what is needed to create, form, realize a thing that defines where we live, what we use and how we live. In this essay the studied topic is some of the theories. This chapter tries to identify the process of design, more than a process of collecting data and processing it till a product is realized. This includes the search of the basis of the design both from the product’s and the producer’s entities. In the western philosophy these five theories are explained to clarify the search of this process.

The first to be explained is the intensive action of thing that are designed that effects the process, as the product itself will be having a use, the design process should be considering these needs to realize the final creation.

The other theory refers to the designer who has a creative mind and individual character, to form the thing. The designers idea is what the product is shaped accordingly.

Third theory is about the ”spirit of the age” or “zeitgeist” which means the time has its own character and identity to effect what is inside, so in design process problem we can approach this theory as the design having been effected by the period of time.

The fourth theory tells that beyond all properties or effects in the design process, the social or economic structure of the place where the process has been taken in will be effecting the product very much. As a design can be realized in a place due to economic conditions but not in a different location due another reason from social or economic conditions.

The last one is as a conclusion to all former theories, the general idea is all good architectural example ( acc. to whom ) will surely have common properties that we can have them generally as a basis for all processes.

The former theories listed above can partially define how the process works but, in fact what lies behind a creation can not be reduced to these theories. Every single design has its own information and meaning inside. However we can classify the design understanding and processes according to different perceptions. But we can not forsee any upcoming thoery in design process though we don’t have any clue about designs that will guide new things.

Murat ÇEVİKAYAK - 152002001

Sources of Architectural Form

Source of architectural form is examined in this article under the basic questions such as; “What is the source of an architect’s design ideas or How is this idea generated, What influences its shape, what is it derived from?” Theorists and theories within the context of the history of western philosophy beginning from the ancient world to the present are mentioned in the article.

In western philosophy five theories are generated to give an aswer for where is the architectural form coming from.

1.“An architectural form is shaped by its intended function”: According to this theory, a good building is shaped by the physical, social,psychological and symbolic functions it is expected to perform. A designer is accepted as a scientist that he/she should explore the client’s needs, climatological conditions, community values and designer avoids preconceptions, gathers together the objective facts about design and draws out the final form.At the end of this theory it is seen that function alone can not explain other influences on building form.

2. “ Architectural form is generated within the creative imagination”: A form of a building depends on inner resources, intutitions of designer. Source of form is appeared according to individual personality. However, if all forms depens on only personality and inner resources, how can we classify buildings as Renaissance, Gothic or how can generic forms as basilica, courtyard, atrium be composed.

3. “ Architectural form is shaped by the prevailing spirit of the age”: This theory accepts that every age has its own spirit and gives shape to buildings. It is thought as a stamp. The problem of this view is; it is insufficient to explain some ages may appear to possess several spirits simultaneously.

4. “Architectural form is determined by the prevailing social and economic conditions”: This theory assets that all individual artistic efforts fall under the coercieveinflunce of larger shared forces. It attributes physical conditions like methods of economic production and distribution prevalent in the architect’s society. Designer can effected from society’s underlying ideological assumptions. But there is no strict connection between socio-economic system and the building form. It can ot explain the different form of buildings in the same society.

5. “ Architectural form derives from timeless principles of form that tanscend particular designers, cultures and climates”: It suggests that certain universal forms underlie all good architecture, no matter what the particular circumstances of the design problem, designer or culture.

This western theories of design cause a paradox in it. Because none of them completely explains how is an architectural form composed. Every theory consists of some insufficient points while answering the question completely. The basement of this paradox in design depends on fundamental assumptions about the individual and his relation to the world.This is known as subject-object problem. It originated in a philosophical system first invented by the ancient Greek. In terms of design theory, the duality created by the subject-object problem between knowing(science) and creating(art) between mind and world.According to this relation, theorists throughout history have articulated variations on six archetypal interpretations of the individual’s relationship to the outside world. Three of these are ostensibly concerned with creation and three are concerned with knowledge.When one view advanced to the forefront in any given period the others were still to be found as minority views in the background or even as anomalies in the other’s concepts. Theories of creation are Classical tradition, Romanticism, Positivism and theories of knowledge are Empricism, Continental Rationalism and German Idealism

Gülnur Vuruşkan

152002002